Saturday, June 7, 2014

Fact Sheet 4: Compare and Contrast on Immanuel Kant and Jacques Derrida

Fact Sheet 4
·         Topic of Blog Post
    • Compare and Contrast of IMMANUEL KANT and JACQUES DERRIDA
IMMANUEL KANT
·         Relevant Definitions
o   Analytic –  a judgment whose truth can be derived solely from the meaning of the words in the sentence; a quality usually attributed to a priori knowledge – for example: “boys are male”
o   A Posteriori – knowledge gained from sensory experience or observation
o   Synthetic – a judgment whose truth is dependent on the world; a quality usually attributed to a posteriori knowledge – for example: “boys are nice”
o   A Priori – knowledge gained independently of sensory experience; can be innate knowledge or knowledge gained through reason
o   Concepts – innate categories of knowledge that help us shape and understand our experiences
o   Empiricism – the epistemological theory which holds that sensory experiences are the source of certain knowledge; propagated by figures such as David Hume
o   Ideas – concepts of knowledge related to transcendental reasoning; reasoning beyond the sensory world
o   Noumenal World – the world that contains things in themselves; this world is above and beyond the boundaries of our experience and reason – thus, the contents of this world are both unknowable and unsensible
o   Phenomenal World – the world which we perceive: this world contains only appearances of things and not things in themselves 
o   Rationalism – the epistemological theory which holds that reason is the source of certain knowledge, and thus, through reason, metaphysical knowledge is possible; propagated by figures such as Rene Descartes
o   Transcendental – going above and beyond experience; an objective reality
o   Transcendental Idealism – the view that while an objective reality does exist… it exists outside of the limits of our knowledge; and thus is unknowable
  • Breakdown of Facts
    • Who –
      • Immanuel Kant – Critique of Pure Reason (1781), Prolegomena to any Future Metaphysics (1783)
        • The Prolegomena deals with the same main issues as the Critique of Pure Reason; the Prolegomena can be viewed as an abridged version of the Critique
    • When –
      • Immanuel Kant was considered a central figure in the era of Modern Philosophy. Although born in 1724, Kant’s prime years were in his later life – beginning around the 1770s. He is known for his contributions to many philosophical fields including epistemology, metaphysics, ethics, and political philosophy.
    • Where –
      • Kant was born in Germany but his works and ideas spread across distance and time to influence philosophers everywhere for centuries to come. Today his is still considered to be one of the most – if not the most – revolutionary figure in Modern Philosophy.
    • Why – 
      • Many of Kant’s works can be viewed as attempts to find middle grounds between the extreme dichotomies presented by the Early Modern philosophers preceding him. For example in The Critique of Pure Reason and thus in the Prolegomena Kant establishes the view of Transcendental Idealism which is an attempt to synthesize the extreme rationalism of Rene Descartes and the extreme empiricism of David Hume.
    • What –
      • Two main points come out of Kant’s Prolegomena and Critique
        • Kant is a Transcendental Idealist – this view is a middle point on the spectrum between rationalism and empiricism
          • The noumenal world – objective reality – exists outside of the bounds of our reason
          • While we can know of this noumenal reality, we can’t know it 
        • Space and Time are neither concepts nor appearances
          • They are forms of experience
          • They are intuitively built into our mental framework
          • They shape how we experience the world


JAQUES DERRIDA
·         Relevant Definitions
o   Differance – a word created by Derrida which replaces the “e” in “difference” with an “a”; differance is a part of the conceptualization of differences – but differance itself is unknowable and undefinable
o   Metaphysics Of Presence – the long standing tradition in Western Philosophy that favors the study of what is spatially and temporally presently is over what is not – or what is absent
o   Word – vehicle for bringing presence into absence
  • Breakdown of Facts
    • Who –
      • Jacques Derrida – Differance (1968)
        • Differance pronounced “differans” was originally given as a speech and later reproduced as an essay.
    • When –
      • Derrida was considered to be the founder of the philosophical movement of Deconstruction. Deconstruction – as a movement – began around the 1960s and had many different centers of focus including ontology, language, and metaphysics.
    • Where –
      • Derrida was born in Algeria, but he spent the majority of his adult life in Paris to study the works of prominent phenomenologists such as Edmund Husserl, Emmanuel Levinas, and Paul Ricoeur.
    • Why –
      • The whole idea behind the movement of Deconstruction was to challenge the centers of focus that had previously arisen in Western Philosophy. For example, Derrida preferred to study difference instead of sameness, absence instead of presence, and the finite over the infinite. In Differance specifically, Derrida examines language through a lens of writing as opposed to through a lens of speech.
    • What –
      • Three important points come out of Derrida’s work Differance:
        • Writing is the act of bringing presence to absence
          •  A written word is meant to stand for something that is absent
        • Differance is not something that can be captured
          • It is neither a word nor a concept
        • The verb – to differ – has multiple connotations
          • Inequality or distinction
          • Spatial and Temporal Impossibility
          • Non – Identity

Works Cited

Grier, Michelle, "Kant's Critique of Metaphysics", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2012 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL = <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2012/entries/kant-metaphysics/>.

Hurst, Andrea. "Derrida's Quasi-Transcendental Thinking." South African Journal of Philosophy 23.3 (2005): 244-266. Print.

Kant, Immanuel, and James W. Ellington. Prolegomena to any future metaphysics that will be able to come forward as science, with Kant's letter to Marcus Herz, February 27, 1772 the Paul Carus translation extensively rev. by James W. Ellington.. 2nd ed. Indianapolis: Hackett Pub., 2001. Print.

Kearney, Richard, and Mara Rainwater. "From Structuralism to Deconstruction.” The Continental philosophy reader. London: Routledge, 1996. 289-304. Print.

Lawlor, Leonard, "Jacques Derrida", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2014 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL = <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2014/entries/derrida/>.

Rohlf, Michael, "Immanuel Kant", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2014 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), forthcoming URL = <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2014/entries/kant/>.

West, David. "Beyond the Subject: Structuralism and Poststructuralism."Continental philosophy: an introduction. 2nd ed. Cambridge, UK: Polity, 2010. 173-208. Print.

No comments:

Post a Comment