Sunday, June 8, 2014

Self Assessment of Blog

When I initially decided to make this blog as my final project for my Contemporary Philosophy class I had the goal of simplifying complex issues to make them understandable. I think that I in part achieved that goal. I think I did a decently good job of making Kant, and Derrida, and Sartre, and Husserl and others decently understandable. But... I think the premise of my initial goal was flawed. I thought that the only way to understand something complex was to make it simple... but I think I was wrong there.

I realized that complex matters are complex matters and that is the bottom line. I realized that the best way to make someone understand something is to explain it... not to simplify it. My uncle likes to creep on what I do sometimes, so he happened to look at my blog. He told me it seemed very smart and thought out and intelligent... but it hurt his brain. I got nervous to hear him say that. I was nervous that I wasn't doing my job of simplifying the issues. I got especially nervous when I noticed how lenghty all of my fact sheets and discussion videos were. I figured there was no way that I was simplyify anything if it was taking me 13 minutes to discuss it.

Again, this thinking was all flawed on my part. If I have learned anything from doing this project it is that philospohy - especially a lot of the issues discussed in contemporary philosophy - are complicated! Bottom line! And they are not meant to be simple. The complexity is what makes them philosphical, what makes them unique, and what makes them intriguing.

But, just because an issue isn't simple doesn't mean it's not understandable. The key to understanding is explaining. That is the takeaway that I give myself from this project. Whenever we would read texts for class the philosophical texts would explain the philosophical theories. And then the in class discussions would explain the philosophical texts. No where was there any simplification. Just explanation. Just breaking down the issues. Just relating the text to outside examples. The class discussions always helped clarify the philosophical issues and theories for me - I think that is due to the explanatory nature of discussion. So that being said now, I realize that it is probably a good thing that my videos are so long and my fact sheets are so lenghty. What I hope it means, is that I took the time to explain everything fully so that it became understandable! :)

To sum up my main takeaway one again... it would be - the key to understanding complex philosophical issues is to explain them not to simplify them. I think also that going into complex philosophy with this mindset makes it seem not so so bad to begin with! And I think that this project also reminded me that the reason I love philosphy so much is because it rasises issues that are intrinsically deep, abstract, and complicated. But hey, what can I say? #ilovephilosophy

********************************************************************************

Sarah Margulis
Drexel University
Philosophy 215
Contemporary Philosophy
June 11, 2014
Final Project 

Discussion Video 4 - Immanuel Kant and Jacques Derrida

Hi All, this is the discussion video that goes along with the fact sheet for the comparison and contrast of Immanuel Kant and Jacques Derrida. I would recommend looking at the video in tandem with the fact sheet seeing as I don't cover everything in the video - I am only discussing one main point of comparison and one main point of contrast. If there is something else specific you would like me to discuss or any questions you might have please leave a comment and let me know! Thanks!






*The sources for all of the quotes that I refer to can be found below. Additionally, the full citation can be found at the bottom of the corresponding fact sheet. 


Here are some passages which I will quote in the video. Please refer to these for reference while watching the video. 

Immanuel Kant Quotes:
  • Now since the transcendental ideas have urged us to approach them and thus have led us, as it were, to the spot where the occupied space touches the void, we can determine the bounds of pure reason… The limits pointed out in those paragraphs are not enough after we have discovered that beyond them there still lies something (though we can never cognize what it is) (Prolegomena, 88).
  • Our representations of space and time are merely intuitions however, ·rather than concepts·; and here is why. Start with empirical intuitions of bodies and their changes, and strip them of everything empirical—i.e. everything you know about them through sensation—and what you are left with is space and time. These are therefore pure intuitions. They must be involved in all empirical intuitions, and can never be omitted, because they underlie everything empirical. But just because they are themselves pure a priori intuitions, they must be mere forms of our sensibility (Prolegomena, 32). 

Jacques Derrida Quotes:

  • By the same token, Derrida’s position involves a significant shift in the understanding of the concept of difference, which plays a central role in Saussure’s account of language as a differential system of oppositions… The notion of differance is specifically designed to disrupt the metaphysics of presence. It does so by reminding us that the recognition of sameness and difference involved in all acts of representation cannot itself be temporally present (West, 199). 
  • Differance is neither a word nor a concept (Kearney and Rainwater, 441)
  • On the other, it [differance] expresses the interposition of delay, the interval of a spacing and temporalizing that puts off until later what is presently denied, the possible that is presently impossible… As distinct from difference, differance thus points out the irreducibility of temporalizing… this would also be called the constitution of primordial temporality – just as the term ‘spacing’ also include the constitution of primordial spatiality (Kearney and Rainwater, 441). 

Discussion Video 3 - Hermeneutics and Structuralism

Hi All, this is the discussion video that goes along with the fact sheet for the comparison and contrast of Hermeneutics and Structuralism. I would recommend looking at the video in tandem with the fact sheet seeing as I don't cover everything in the video - I am only discussing one main point of comparison and one main point of contrast. If there is something else specific you would like me to discuss or any questions you might have please leave a comment and let me know! Thanks!




* My apologies for the quality of this video. The sound and the video don't seem to quite sync up... but hopefully everything should still make sense :)

**The sources for all of the quotes that I refer to can be found below. Additionally, the full citation can be found at the bottom of the corresponding fact sheet. 

Here are some passages which I will quote in the video. Please refer to these for reference while watching the video. 

Hans-Georg Gadamer Quotes:


  • The first is the essential self-forgetfulness that belongs to language. The structure, grammar, syntax of language… are not at all conscious to living speaking. Hence one of the peculiar perversions of the natural that is necessary for modern education is that we teach grammar and syntax in our own native language – (Man and Language, 64)
  • Gadamer's positive conception of prejudice as pre-judgment is connected with a number of different ideas in his hermeneutics. The way in which our prejudgments open us up to the matter at issue in such a way that those prejudgments are themselves capable of being revised exhibits the character of the Gadamerian conception of prejudgment, and its role in understanding, as itself constituting a version of the hermeneutic circle (Malpas).
  • The second essential feature of the being of language seems to me to be its I-lessness. Whoever speaks a language that no one else understands does not speak. To speak means to speak to someone (Man and Language, 65). 

Ferdinand de Saussure Quotes:

  • The linguist must take the study of linguistic structure as his primary concern, and relate all other manifestations of language to it (Kearney and Rainwater, 292).
  • Without moving either lips or tongue, we can talk to ourselves or recite silently a piece of verse. We grasp the words of a language as sound patterns. That is why it I best to avoid referring to them as composed of ‘speech sounds’ (Kearney and Rainwater, 300)

Saturday, June 7, 2014

Fact Sheet 4: Compare and Contrast on Immanuel Kant and Jacques Derrida

Fact Sheet 4
·         Topic of Blog Post
    • Compare and Contrast of IMMANUEL KANT and JACQUES DERRIDA
IMMANUEL KANT
·         Relevant Definitions
o   Analytic –  a judgment whose truth can be derived solely from the meaning of the words in the sentence; a quality usually attributed to a priori knowledge – for example: “boys are male”
o   A Posteriori – knowledge gained from sensory experience or observation
o   Synthetic – a judgment whose truth is dependent on the world; a quality usually attributed to a posteriori knowledge – for example: “boys are nice”
o   A Priori – knowledge gained independently of sensory experience; can be innate knowledge or knowledge gained through reason
o   Concepts – innate categories of knowledge that help us shape and understand our experiences
o   Empiricism – the epistemological theory which holds that sensory experiences are the source of certain knowledge; propagated by figures such as David Hume
o   Ideas – concepts of knowledge related to transcendental reasoning; reasoning beyond the sensory world
o   Noumenal World – the world that contains things in themselves; this world is above and beyond the boundaries of our experience and reason – thus, the contents of this world are both unknowable and unsensible
o   Phenomenal World – the world which we perceive: this world contains only appearances of things and not things in themselves 
o   Rationalism – the epistemological theory which holds that reason is the source of certain knowledge, and thus, through reason, metaphysical knowledge is possible; propagated by figures such as Rene Descartes
o   Transcendental – going above and beyond experience; an objective reality
o   Transcendental Idealism – the view that while an objective reality does exist… it exists outside of the limits of our knowledge; and thus is unknowable
  • Breakdown of Facts
    • Who –
      • Immanuel Kant – Critique of Pure Reason (1781), Prolegomena to any Future Metaphysics (1783)
        • The Prolegomena deals with the same main issues as the Critique of Pure Reason; the Prolegomena can be viewed as an abridged version of the Critique
    • When –
      • Immanuel Kant was considered a central figure in the era of Modern Philosophy. Although born in 1724, Kant’s prime years were in his later life – beginning around the 1770s. He is known for his contributions to many philosophical fields including epistemology, metaphysics, ethics, and political philosophy.
    • Where –
      • Kant was born in Germany but his works and ideas spread across distance and time to influence philosophers everywhere for centuries to come. Today his is still considered to be one of the most – if not the most – revolutionary figure in Modern Philosophy.
    • Why – 
      • Many of Kant’s works can be viewed as attempts to find middle grounds between the extreme dichotomies presented by the Early Modern philosophers preceding him. For example in The Critique of Pure Reason and thus in the Prolegomena Kant establishes the view of Transcendental Idealism which is an attempt to synthesize the extreme rationalism of Rene Descartes and the extreme empiricism of David Hume.
    • What –
      • Two main points come out of Kant’s Prolegomena and Critique
        • Kant is a Transcendental Idealist – this view is a middle point on the spectrum between rationalism and empiricism
          • The noumenal world – objective reality – exists outside of the bounds of our reason
          • While we can know of this noumenal reality, we can’t know it 
        • Space and Time are neither concepts nor appearances
          • They are forms of experience
          • They are intuitively built into our mental framework
          • They shape how we experience the world


JAQUES DERRIDA
·         Relevant Definitions
o   Differance – a word created by Derrida which replaces the “e” in “difference” with an “a”; differance is a part of the conceptualization of differences – but differance itself is unknowable and undefinable
o   Metaphysics Of Presence – the long standing tradition in Western Philosophy that favors the study of what is spatially and temporally presently is over what is not – or what is absent
o   Word – vehicle for bringing presence into absence
  • Breakdown of Facts
    • Who –
      • Jacques Derrida – Differance (1968)
        • Differance pronounced “differans” was originally given as a speech and later reproduced as an essay.
    • When –
      • Derrida was considered to be the founder of the philosophical movement of Deconstruction. Deconstruction – as a movement – began around the 1960s and had many different centers of focus including ontology, language, and metaphysics.
    • Where –
      • Derrida was born in Algeria, but he spent the majority of his adult life in Paris to study the works of prominent phenomenologists such as Edmund Husserl, Emmanuel Levinas, and Paul Ricoeur.
    • Why –
      • The whole idea behind the movement of Deconstruction was to challenge the centers of focus that had previously arisen in Western Philosophy. For example, Derrida preferred to study difference instead of sameness, absence instead of presence, and the finite over the infinite. In Differance specifically, Derrida examines language through a lens of writing as opposed to through a lens of speech.
    • What –
      • Three important points come out of Derrida’s work Differance:
        • Writing is the act of bringing presence to absence
          •  A written word is meant to stand for something that is absent
        • Differance is not something that can be captured
          • It is neither a word nor a concept
        • The verb – to differ – has multiple connotations
          • Inequality or distinction
          • Spatial and Temporal Impossibility
          • Non – Identity

Works Cited

Grier, Michelle, "Kant's Critique of Metaphysics", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2012 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL = <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2012/entries/kant-metaphysics/>.

Hurst, Andrea. "Derrida's Quasi-Transcendental Thinking." South African Journal of Philosophy 23.3 (2005): 244-266. Print.

Kant, Immanuel, and James W. Ellington. Prolegomena to any future metaphysics that will be able to come forward as science, with Kant's letter to Marcus Herz, February 27, 1772 the Paul Carus translation extensively rev. by James W. Ellington.. 2nd ed. Indianapolis: Hackett Pub., 2001. Print.

Kearney, Richard, and Mara Rainwater. "From Structuralism to Deconstruction.” The Continental philosophy reader. London: Routledge, 1996. 289-304. Print.

Lawlor, Leonard, "Jacques Derrida", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2014 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL = <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2014/entries/derrida/>.

Rohlf, Michael, "Immanuel Kant", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2014 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), forthcoming URL = <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2014/entries/kant/>.

West, David. "Beyond the Subject: Structuralism and Poststructuralism."Continental philosophy: an introduction. 2nd ed. Cambridge, UK: Polity, 2010. 173-208. Print.

Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Fact Sheet 3 - Compare and Contrast on Hermeneutics and Structuralism

Fact Sheet 3
·         Topic of Blog Post
    • Compare and Contrast of HERMENEUTICS and STRUCTURALISM
HERMENEUTICS
·         Relevant Definitions
o   Animal Rationale – Greek phrase that literally means ‘the rational being’; follows Aristotle’s belief that human capacity for though is what distinguishes humans from all other animals
o   Hermeneutics – an area of study that deals with text interpretation – originally interpretation of the bible; however, nowadays hermeneutics can be applied to many different fields
o   Horizontsverschmelzung – German phrase that literally means ‘fusion of horizons’; in Hermeneutics it refers to the process of individuals coming to an agreement and reaching a common framework of understanding
o   I-Lessness – the property of human language that states that speaking cannot exist in the sphere of “I” but only in the sphere of  “we”
o   Logos – Greek word commonly taken to mean ‘logic’, but what Aristotle meant it to mean was ‘language’
o   Self-Forgetfulness – the idea that grammar and syntax of a language are easily forgettable – and must be taught – because they are not a conscious part of live speaking
o   Universality of Language – the idea that all things fundamental to human experience can somehow be expressed through language; language excludes nothing
o   Verstehen – German word meaning understanding
o   Vorurteil German word meaning prejudice – but prejudice here is taken to mean pre-understanding; refers to prior knowledge
o   Wirkungsgeschichte – German word that literally means ‘effective history’; this refers to the idea that understanding is always an effect of our history, tradition, or upbringing
  • Breakdown of Facts
    • Who –
      • The following author’s works are known to be the foundational works for twentieth century hermeneutics.
      • He was a student of the phenomenologist Martin Heidegger, and adapted many of Heidegger’s ideas into his own works.
        • Hans-Georg Gadamer – The Universality of the Hermeneutical Problem (1966) Man and Language (1966), part of  Philosophical Hermeneutics
    • When –
      • The field of Hermeneutics (text interpretation) has been around since the time of the Ancient Greeks. However, Hermeneutics as philosophical movement began to form in the 1920’s along with the growth of German Romanticism and German Idealism.
    • Where –
      • Twentieth Century Hermeneutics began in Germany but quickly spread across Europe and even spread to England and the United States where it was adapted in an Anglo-American philosophical context.
    • Why –  
      • This new era of Hermeneutical thinking arose to put an ontological spin on Hermeneutics beginning to examine bot human being and human existence through language.

    • What –
      • Three main points come out of Gadamer:
        • Prejudice is nothing more than prior understanding and is a positive asset to text interpretation
          • Understanding of a text is a pre-requisite for interpretation of a text
          • Prejudice is rooted in – and cannot be separated from – our existence as historical beings
        • No objectivity can exist without subjectivity
          • Subjectivity is what allows for agreement and disagreement in Hermeneutics
        • There exist three essential features of human language:
          • Self-Forgetfulness
          • I-Lessness
          • Universality


STRUCTURALISM
·         Relevant Definitions
o   Concept – the greater, abstract idea or meaning attached to a term
o   Diachronic – studying language through its changes and developments over time
o   Exclamation – a word where the tone –  or way in which the word is spoken – dictates the meaning
o   Language System–system that can be studied distinctly of speech – for example languages no longer spoken can still be studied; the structure of a     language
o   Morphemes – smallest units of language to have meaning; examples would be words, prefixes, suffixes
o   Onomatopoeia – a group of words where the sound that the word makes is directly related to the meaning of the word
o   Phonemes – smallest units of sound used to distinguish the sound of one word from the sound of another; example would be the sounds made by letters in different words
o   Semantics – meaning of a sentence; truth value
o   Semiology – the science or study of signs
o   Sign – combination of a concept and sound pattern in linguistics
o   Signified – a word that can be used interchangeably with sound pattern; refers to the sound portion of a sign
o   Signifier – a word that can be used interchangeably with concept; refers to the meaning portion of a sign
o   Sound Pattern – the hearer’s psychological impression of a sound – representative of but not equivalent to sensory impressions
o   Synchronic – a method involving studying the inner working of language at any given point in time; a scientific way to study language
o   Syntax – rules used for arranging words into grammatically correct structures (sentences), syntax can examined independently of semantics

  • Breakdown of Facts
    • Who –
      • The following author and his revolutionary works are best known for beginning the development of Structuralism in philosophy.
        • Ferdinand de Saussure – Course in General Linguistics (1916)
    • When –
      • Structuralism as a philosophical movement began around the turn of the twentieth century and continued to develop well into the 1950’s and 1960’s.
    • Where –
      • Structuralism’s initial roots are in Switzerland – specifically Geneva – where Saussure lived and taught. Saussure also taught in Paris, and after his death in 1913 the Structuralism movement began to grow rapidly in France.
    • Why –
      • Structuralism grew as a radically different method for studying language than the historical and referential methods that were common of the time. Structural method was based in semiology and in the study of language as a system.
    • What –
      • Four crucial points come out of Saussure
        • Language cannot merely be studied diachronically – or from a historical lens – it must be studied analytically, based on its structure
        • The primary structure of language is signs
          • Signs are composed of signifier (sound pattern) and signified (concept)
            • Phonemes are the smallest unit of sound used to differentiate one sound pattern from another
        • The relationship between signifier and signified is arbitrary; different sounds can express the same idea
          • There exist two exceptions to this rule
            • Onomatopoeia
            • Exclamations
        • The process of speaking has three components
          • Psychological component
          • Physiological component
          • Physical component

Works Cited

Gadamer, Hans-Georg.  "Man and Language."  In Philosophical Hermeneutics, translated and edited by David E. Linge, 59-68.  Berkeley: University of California Press, 2008.

Kearney, Richard, and Mara Rainwater. "From Phenomenology to Hermeneutics."The Continental philosophy reader. London: Routledge, 1996. 109-121. Print.

Kearney, Richard, and Mara Rainwater. "From Structuralism to Deconstruction.” The Continental philosophy reader. London: Routledge, 1996. 289-304. Print.

Malpas, Jeff, "Hans-Georg Gadamer", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2013 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL = <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2013/entries/gadamer/>.

Ramberg, Bjørn and Gjesdal, Kristin, "Hermeneutics", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2013 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL = <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2013/entries/hermeneutics/>.

Tuesday, May 6, 2014

Discussion Video 2 - Existentialism

Hi All, this is the discussion video that goes along with the fact sheet for Existentialism. I would recommend looking at the video in tandem with the fact sheet seeing as I don't cover everything in the video... I only discuss the most important points. If there is something else specific you would like me to discuss or any questions you might have please leave a comment and let me know! Thanks!



* The video got cut slightly short at the end, but all that was missed was me saying that if you have any questions or anything else you want to know to post it in a comment and I will try to answer it! :)

** Just to clarify a point from the video above, both Sartre and Merleau-Ponty believe that the consciousness is both disembodied and embodied. When I say that Sartre believes the consciousness is disembodied I merely mean that Sartre does not believe the body needs to be taken into account to describe the consciousness. Merleau-Ponty, on the other hand, believes that the consciousness cannot be accurately described without taking the body into account. 

Here are some passages which I will quote in the video. Please refer to these for reference while watching the video. 


·         Jean Paul Sartre Quotes:

o   There are, on the one hand, the Christians, amongst whom I shall name Jaspers and Gabriel Marcel, both professed Catholics; and on the other the existential atheists, amongst who we must place Heidegger as well as the French existentialists and myself. What they have in common is simply the fact that they believe that existence comes before essence – or, if you will, that we must begin from the subjective.
§  (Existentialism and Humanism)

o   If, however, it is true that existence is prior to essence, man is responsible for what he is.
§  (Existentialism and Humanism)

o   Man is the future of man. That is exactly true.
§  (Existentialism and Humanism)

·         Maurice Merleau-Ponty Quotes:

o   I must be the exterior that I present to others, and the body of the other must be the other himself. This paradox and the dialectic of the Ego and the Alter are possible only provided that the Ego and the Alter Ego are defined by their situation and are not freed from all inherence; that is, provided that philosophy does not culminate in a return to the self, and that I discover by reflection not only my presence to myself, but also the possibility of an ‘outside spectator’; that is, again, provided that at the very moment when I experience my existence – at the ultimate extremity of reflection – I fall short of the ultimate density which would place me outside time… 
§  (Phenomenology of Perception, Preface)

·         Simone de Beauvoir Quotes:

o   Now what peculiarly signalizes the situation of women is that she – a free and autonomous being like all human creatures – nevertheless finds herself living in a world where men compel her to assume the status of the Other. They propose to stabilize her as object and to doom her to immanence since her transcendence is to be overshadowed and forever transcended by another ego which is essential and soverign.
§  (The Second Sex, Introduction).

o   The terms masculine and feminine are used symmetrically only as a matter of form, as on legal papers. In actuality the relation of the two sexes is not quite like that of two electrical poles, for man represents both the positive and the neutral, as indicated by the common use of man to designate human beings in general; whereas woman represents only the negative, defined by limiting criteria, without reciprocity.

§  (The Second Sex, Introduction).