Sunday, June 8, 2014

Discussion Video 4 - Immanuel Kant and Jacques Derrida

Hi All, this is the discussion video that goes along with the fact sheet for the comparison and contrast of Immanuel Kant and Jacques Derrida. I would recommend looking at the video in tandem with the fact sheet seeing as I don't cover everything in the video - I am only discussing one main point of comparison and one main point of contrast. If there is something else specific you would like me to discuss or any questions you might have please leave a comment and let me know! Thanks!






*The sources for all of the quotes that I refer to can be found below. Additionally, the full citation can be found at the bottom of the corresponding fact sheet. 


Here are some passages which I will quote in the video. Please refer to these for reference while watching the video. 

Immanuel Kant Quotes:
  • Now since the transcendental ideas have urged us to approach them and thus have led us, as it were, to the spot where the occupied space touches the void, we can determine the bounds of pure reason… The limits pointed out in those paragraphs are not enough after we have discovered that beyond them there still lies something (though we can never cognize what it is) (Prolegomena, 88).
  • Our representations of space and time are merely intuitions however, ·rather than concepts·; and here is why. Start with empirical intuitions of bodies and their changes, and strip them of everything empirical—i.e. everything you know about them through sensation—and what you are left with is space and time. These are therefore pure intuitions. They must be involved in all empirical intuitions, and can never be omitted, because they underlie everything empirical. But just because they are themselves pure a priori intuitions, they must be mere forms of our sensibility (Prolegomena, 32). 

Jacques Derrida Quotes:

  • By the same token, Derrida’s position involves a significant shift in the understanding of the concept of difference, which plays a central role in Saussure’s account of language as a differential system of oppositions… The notion of differance is specifically designed to disrupt the metaphysics of presence. It does so by reminding us that the recognition of sameness and difference involved in all acts of representation cannot itself be temporally present (West, 199). 
  • Differance is neither a word nor a concept (Kearney and Rainwater, 441)
  • On the other, it [differance] expresses the interposition of delay, the interval of a spacing and temporalizing that puts off until later what is presently denied, the possible that is presently impossible… As distinct from difference, differance thus points out the irreducibility of temporalizing… this would also be called the constitution of primordial temporality – just as the term ‘spacing’ also include the constitution of primordial spatiality (Kearney and Rainwater, 441). 

No comments:

Post a Comment