Sunday, June 8, 2014

Discussion Video 3 - Hermeneutics and Structuralism

Hi All, this is the discussion video that goes along with the fact sheet for the comparison and contrast of Hermeneutics and Structuralism. I would recommend looking at the video in tandem with the fact sheet seeing as I don't cover everything in the video - I am only discussing one main point of comparison and one main point of contrast. If there is something else specific you would like me to discuss or any questions you might have please leave a comment and let me know! Thanks!




* My apologies for the quality of this video. The sound and the video don't seem to quite sync up... but hopefully everything should still make sense :)

**The sources for all of the quotes that I refer to can be found below. Additionally, the full citation can be found at the bottom of the corresponding fact sheet. 

Here are some passages which I will quote in the video. Please refer to these for reference while watching the video. 

Hans-Georg Gadamer Quotes:


  • The first is the essential self-forgetfulness that belongs to language. The structure, grammar, syntax of language… are not at all conscious to living speaking. Hence one of the peculiar perversions of the natural that is necessary for modern education is that we teach grammar and syntax in our own native language – (Man and Language, 64)
  • Gadamer's positive conception of prejudice as pre-judgment is connected with a number of different ideas in his hermeneutics. The way in which our prejudgments open us up to the matter at issue in such a way that those prejudgments are themselves capable of being revised exhibits the character of the Gadamerian conception of prejudgment, and its role in understanding, as itself constituting a version of the hermeneutic circle (Malpas).
  • The second essential feature of the being of language seems to me to be its I-lessness. Whoever speaks a language that no one else understands does not speak. To speak means to speak to someone (Man and Language, 65). 

Ferdinand de Saussure Quotes:

  • The linguist must take the study of linguistic structure as his primary concern, and relate all other manifestations of language to it (Kearney and Rainwater, 292).
  • Without moving either lips or tongue, we can talk to ourselves or recite silently a piece of verse. We grasp the words of a language as sound patterns. That is why it I best to avoid referring to them as composed of ‘speech sounds’ (Kearney and Rainwater, 300)

No comments:

Post a Comment